IDAHO FALLS, ID — A new episode of KSL’s Deceived: The Daybell Story takes listeners back to the June 9, 2020, search of Chad Daybell’s Fremont County property, where investigators eventually found the remains of JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan.
The episode, titled Feel the Fire, uses firsthand accounts from law enforcement officers who were at the scene to reconstruct how the search unfolded. At the time, the children had been missing for nearly nine months, and officers were focused on finding them or uncovering evidence that could lead them to the answers families had been waiting for.
Host Nate Eaton describes the day through the eyes of the investigators who took part in the operation. By the end of the search, Chad Daybell was arrested, and relatives of the children finally received confirmation of what had happened, even as many questions remained unanswered.
How investigators moved in on the property
According to the episode, dozens of officers from agencies across eastern Idaho, along with the FBI, arrived on Daybell’s property early that morning to serve a warrant. The search began around 7 a.m. and was part of a broader effort to locate the missing children.
Rexburg Police Lt. Ray Hermosillo tells Eaton that investigators watched Daybell closely as they worked. He described him rubbing his hands through his hair, putting his hat back on, and looking down at the ground while the search continued. Those movements, Hermosillo said, made him suspect that something significant might be found on the property.
The episode presents the search as both a law enforcement operation and an emotionally charged moment, with officers balancing the demands of the investigation against the possibility that they were closing in on a grim discovery.
What officers found in the backyard
The search ended with one of the most disturbing discoveries in the case. Under a tree in the backyard, investigators found JJ Vallow, the 7-year-old boy they had been searching for.
Nearby, in a fire pit, officers also found some of Tylee Ryan’s remains. The discovery confirmed what investigators had feared and brought a painful turning point in a case that had already drawn intense attention from law enforcement and the children’s relatives.
Hermosillo said that while police are trained to handle difficult scenes, the reality of finding children changes the experience. He explained that officers can prepare for such work, but the emotional impact is harder to avoid when they have families and children of their own.
The emotional toll on investigators at the scene
Feel the Fire also focuses on the burden carried by the officers who took part in the recovery effort. Hermosillo’s account highlights the tension between professional detachment and the human reaction that comes with searching for missing children.
He said investigators have to keep working even when the scene is overwhelming. The episode uses those reflections to show how the search affected the people involved long after the physical work was finished.
That perspective adds another layer to the Daybell case, which has been marked not just by legal developments but also by the emotional strain on families, detectives, and others who spent months looking for the children. The podcast episode gives those officers room to describe the day in their own words.
A phone call between sisters after the discovery
The episode also includes a recorded phone call between Summer Shiflet and her sister Lori after Shiflet learned that her niece and nephew had been killed and buried on Daybell’s property. In the conversation, Shiflet confronts Lori with her anger and confusion over what happened.
Shiflet can be heard saying she does not know what to think and that none of the family has been given answers. Lori was incarcerated in the Madison County Jail at the time of the call.
That exchange underscores how the discovery affected the children’s relatives, who were left trying to process the news while still searching for clarity. The episode frames the call as part of the family’s immediate emotional response to the revelations from the property search.
Where listeners can hear the episode and learn more
KSL says Episode 4 of DeceivedFeel the Fire, is available on podcast platforms now. The company is also directing listeners to the KSL Podcasts website for more information about the series.
For those looking for more background on the case, KSL also points to its Daybell case archive, which collects coverage related to the investigation and the events surrounding the search. The episode adds a detailed, personal view of one of the most consequential days in the case.
By revisiting the search through the voices of officers and family members, the episode places the discovery of JJ and Tylee’s remains at the center of a story that has continued to unfold for years.
